On Wednesday, a teen named Andy Fuentes put up a selfie of him and his girlfriend on Twitter. The caption read, “i love my girlfriend even if shes a gemini,” and on first glance it seems like a fairly average photo.

Until, wait a minute…

WHAT THE HELL IS THAT?

It looks like there is an evil version of her in the mirror, smiling as if to say, “Enjoy him now, because soon he will be mine.”

It brought back all kinds of traumatic memories of those terrifying R.L. Stine stories in which your reflection was always plotting to kill you. And people were shook.

Now, while Andy has yet to respond to Seventeen.com‘s request for comment, it’s safe to assume that this is just some expert photoshopping on his part. One Twitter user made the astute observation that he did it because his girlfriend is a gemini, and geminis are known to have two faces.

Still freaky though.